When deciding whether to hire a private in-home caregiver or work with a home care agency, families should consider their priorities and the tradeoffs associated with each option. For example, hiring a caregiver directly may cost less, but it also means taking on the responsibilities of being an employer, such as recruiting, scheduling, payroll, taxes, and finding backup care. Understanding how these two in-home care options differ can help families weigh the benefits and tradeoffs of each approach and choose the one that best meets their loved one’s needs.
Is home care the right fit?
Let our free assessment guide you to the best senior living options, tailored to your needs.
The primary difference between a private caregiver and a home care agency is who employs and manages the caregiver. A private in-home caregiver is hired directly by the family, making the family responsible for recruiting, supervising, paying, and managing the caregiver. In contrast, caregivers hired through a home care agency are agency employees, so the agency oversees scheduling, payroll, training, supervision, and replacement caregivers if the regular caregiver is unavailable.
Whether hired privately or through an agency, professional caregivers can provide many of the same in-home care services and often have experience supporting seniors who wish to remain at home. The choice between these options typically comes down to whether a family prefers lower costs and greater control or the convenience and support an agency provides.
Is home care the right fit?
Let our free assessment guide you to the best senior living options, tailored to your needs.
Every family’s situation is different. Before deciding whether to hire a caregiver directly or work with an agency, consider the tradeoffs in these areas.
Hiring a caregiver directly is often less expensive because families pay only the caregiver’s wages. Home care agencies charge more because their rates also cover recruiting, supervision, scheduling, training, payroll, and benefits.
“The main reason families hire private caregivers is the lower cost,” says Amanda Lambert, who coauthored Aging with Care: Your Guide to Hiring and Managing Caregivers at Home with Leslie Eckford, a nurse and geriatric clinical social worker.
Tradeoff: Families who hire directly are responsible for tasks such as payroll, taxes, scheduling, and finding replacement coverage when needed.
“For 10 hours or fewer it may be financially less expensive, but as the hours grow the dynamic changes,” says Vicki Demirozu, founder of Giving Care with Grace, a soft skills training program for caregivers. “It’s often a tradeoff between saving money and saving time, effort, and risk.”
Home care agencies ensure backup coverage if a caregiver is sick, unavailable, or leaves the job. Agencies also supervise caregivers, provide training, and help ensure care remains appropriate as needs change.
“With an agency, the family is paying not only for the caregiver’s time, but also for the peace of mind,” says Demirozu. “This includes backup staffing in case of caregiver illness or emergencies, supervision, and quality assurance to ensure the caregiver and client continue to be a good match, as a client condition may worsen or improve.
Demirozu also points out that agencies handle workman’s compensation and employment liability protection and can act as a resource to the family for education and support.
Tradeoff: Agencies usually can’t guarantee the same caregiver for every visit, which may make it harder to build a consistent relationship.
Hiring directly gives families more control over who provides care and how that care is delivered. Families can select the caregiver themselves and communicate directly about preferences and expectations.
“Many people want to select the person who will care for their loved one,” Eckford says.
Tradeoff: Families are responsible for screening candidates, conducting background checks, complying with employment laws, and managing potential legal or liability risks.[01]
| Consideration | Private caregiver | Home care agency |
|---|---|---|
| Who manages care | You coordinate hiring, scheduling, and oversight | The agency manages day-to-day operations |
| Time commitment | Ongoing time for coordination and management | Less day-to-day coordination required |
| Cost | Lower hourly rates, but added time and potential indirect costs | Higher hourly rates that include support and coverage |
| Risk and responsibility | You take on employer-related responsibilities | The agency assumes most employment responsibilities |
| Involvement in decisions | More direct involvement in caregiver selection and communication | You share preferences while the agency manages matching and oversight |
| Reliability | You arrange backup if needed | The agency typically provides backup coverage |
Home care questions? Get expert help
Tell us your care needs to receive personalized guidance from our advisors.
Your situation, including your budget, personal preferences, and your capacity to take on various responsibilities, will determine whether hiring an in-home caretaker directly or hiring through an agency is best for you.
For example, if dependable coverage and backup support are your top priorities, working with a home care agency may be the better fit. If having more control over who provides care and how that care is delivered is most important to you, hiring a caregiver directly may be the better option, provided you’re comfortable managing responsibilities such as hiring, scheduling, payroll, and taxes.
| Your priority | May be a good fit |
|---|---|
| You want more control over selecting the caregiver | Hiring a caregiver directly |
| You want less administrative work | Using a home care agency |
| You need dependable backup coverage | Using a home care agency |
| You’re comfortable managing hiring and scheduling | Hiring a caregiver directly |
| You’re balancing multiple responsibilities and need support | Using a home care agency |
If you’re planning to work with a home care agency, begin researching and contacting agencies to compare services, availability, and understand how they manage the work of their caregivers. If you’d prefer support along the way, a Senior Living Advisor from A Place for Mom can help talk through your options, compare agencies, and connect with local providers.
Ask each agency how they hire, train, supervise, and support their caregivers. You can also read reviews and testimonials from clients and caregivers online to learn about the agency’s reputation, responsiveness, and quality of care.
A quality agency will always meet with clients before starting services to prepare a care plan that includes the client’s hobbies and personal preferences, as well as their physical, cognitive, and medical care needs, to ensure their caregiver has the correct training.
Agencies try to be consistent by sending the same caregivers, unless the caregiver is ill or has an emergency. When a caregiver isn’t able to work, the agency has a care plan for your loved one, and so can make a match in the meantime until their regular caregiver can return.
IRS. (2026, January 16). Hiring household employees.
The information contained on this page is for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute medical, legal or financial advice or create a professional relationship between A Place for Mom and the reader. Always seek the advice of your health care provider, attorney or financial advisor with respect to any particular matter, and do not act or refrain from acting on the basis of anything you have read on this site. Links to third-party websites are only for the convenience of the reader; A Place for Mom does not endorse the contents of the third-party sites.